Employee or contractor? A test before you pay a freelancer.
Employee vs contractor in Canada: a plain test for agency and SaaS owners paying freelancers, plus what a T4A slip is and what changes for developers abroad.
The takeaway
A freelancer is more likely a contractor when they run their own business: they decide how and when the work gets done, bring their own tools, can send someone else in their place and carry the risk of a loss. For a contractor in Canada you pay more than $500 in a calendar year, the CRA generally expects a T4A slip by the last day of February of the next year, and a developer abroad has its own rules. Someone who works set hours under your direction is more likely an employee, and that means payroll.
You have a freelance designer, developer or copywriter you pay every month, and you are not sure if they count as an employee. The invoice says contractor. The CRA does not go by what the invoice says.
This is for owners of agencies, studios and software companies with a small team. Below: the six things the CRA looks at, what you owe at the end of the year for a real contractor, and what changes if the developer lives outside Canada.
Who decides if a freelancer is a contractor?
The facts of the working relationship decide, not the label or the contract. The CRA looks at each of six factors on its own and then at all of them together.
Control matters most to people in practice. The CRA says the right to direct how the work is done counts, even if you never use it.
| Factor | Points to a contractor | Points to an employee |
|---|---|---|
| Control | They decide how and when to do the work | You direct how, when and where |
| Tools and equipment | They bring and pay for their own | You supply the laptop and software |
| Helpers | They can hire someone to do or help with the work | They must do the work personally |
| Financial risk | They carry unpaid expenses and pay to fix their own mistakes | They have no costs or risk of their own |
| Investment and management | They run a business, with their own clients and costs | They work inside yours |
| Chance of profit | They can make a profit or take a loss on the job | Paid for time, no upside or downside |
If most rows point to the right-hand column, plan for an employee. If you cannot tell, you can ask the CRA for a ruling on Form CPT1.
What does the answer change for your agency?
It changes who handles the tax on that person's pay. A contractor looks after their own income tax, and you pay the invoice. An employee needs payroll: you deduct income tax, CPP and EI and add your own share.
If the CRA decides someone was an employee, you can owe both the employer and employee share of the CPP and EI you did not deduct, plus penalties and interest.
Do you issue a T4A slip to a contractor?
Generally yes. The CRA expects a T4A slip when you pay fees for services of more than $500 in a calendar year. A T4A slip is a one-page summary of what you paid, sent to the person and filed with the CRA. The CRA describes this as reporting fees paid to other businesses, so if you are unsure it covers a particular freelancer or company, ask your accountant.
You report the fees without GST/HST, in the calendar year you paid them, whenever the work was done. The CRA says slips go to the recipient by the last day of February of the next year, and the slips and T4A summary are filed by their due date (the next business day if it falls on a weekend).
As of November 2026, the CRA says it is not assessing penalties for failure relating to box 048 outside the trucking industry, where penalties apply from the 2025 tax year. The reporting requirement itself still stands and the CRA's position can change, so check before you file.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| 12 invoices before HST | $9,600 |
| Over $500 for the year? | Yes, issue a T4A |
| Amount in the fees box (box 048) | $9,600, without HST |
| Due | Last day of February next year (next business day if a weekend) |
What if your developer lives outside Canada?
If they do the work outside Canada, the CRA's non-resident withholding rule does not apply to that part of the fee. If they work in Canada while living elsewhere, the rule says you withhold 15% of the fee and send it to the CRA by the 15th of the next month.
For example, you pay a developer based in another country $15,000 for a project, and $6,000 of that is for weeks they spend working on site in Halifax. You withhold 15% of the $6,000, which is $900, and the other $9,000 is for work done abroad.
If a payment covers work in and out of Canada, write down a reasonable split. The CRA suggests withholding on the whole payment when there is no record of it.
For fees paid to a non-resident for services performed in Canada, the CRA's circular says you report them on a T4A-NR, not a T4A, by the last day of February of the next year. The T4A-NR is needed whatever the amount, even if the CRA granted a waiver.
What should you do this week?
List everyone you paid as a freelancer this year and note, for each one:
- Their name, address and the total you paid in the year, before HST.
- Who set the hours and the method, who supplied the tools, and whether they can send a substitute.
- Where the work was done, if they live outside Canada.
- Anyone who looks like an employee, so you can decide on a fix before February.
If the list shows grey areas, ISKRQ can sort the year's contractor payments, prepare the T4A slips and summary, and flag people to review with your accountant. Bring your payment records and a note on how each person works with you.
Further reading
A practical next step
Let’s make your numbers easier to work with.
Tell us what you need help with. We’ll arrange a free 20-minute call to discuss the next steps.
Request a call